Your browser does not support JavaScript! Skip to main content

In a whirlwind of nostalgia that has captured the collective fascination, the latest Hulu documentary delves deep into the captivating realm of high societies, transporting us to the realms we once avidly devoured through tabloids and television shows.

With an enchanting blend of personal narratives from the socialites themselves, Queenmaker emerges onto the scene, igniting fervent discussions and breathing fresh life into the ongoing dialogue. But does this exquisite production truly offer a unique perspective that enriches the discourse?

What is Queenmaker: The Making of an It Girl’ about?

A generation of affluent young women emerged, driven by a burning desire to emulate the iconic Paris Hilton and Tinsley Mortimer, their hunger for success palpable. As the night unfolded, every red carpet became a stage for ostentatious displays of wealth, where these socialites spared no expense in outshining one another.

In the year 2007, New York City transformed into an unprecedented realm of extravagance, catapulting socialites into the realm of true celebrities, capturing the essence of excess in a public spectacle like never before.


Amidst this whirlwind of drama and often merciless publications, a clandestine virtual haven emerged under the name of Park Avenue Peerage. Contrary to expectations, this enigmatic website took a different path, offering a subtle understanding and admiration for the very women who faced relentless daily attacks from the tabloid media. The identity of the anonymous blogger behind this unexpected oasis? Hard to guess.

Beyond the glimmer and opulence, Queenmaker stands as a profound tale—a tale of a young outsider grappling with an identity intricately woven by the indomitable forces of mainstream white American culture that have shaped generations of young women.

It unravels the essence of this narrative, weaving together the threads of glamour and vulnerability, and casting light on the struggles faced by those yearning to break free from society’s preconceived molds.

What is the Inspiration behind Hulu’s Queenmaker?

Let us first clarify that this remarkable production should not be mistaken for the recent Netflix K-drama of the same name. In its initial half, Queenmaker unfurls before us the resplendent lives of the wealthy and renowned, evoking the spirit of cinematic gems like Born Rich and The One Percent. The allure of opulence and grandeur cascades from the screen, inviting us into a realm where the rich and famous reign supreme.


However, as the film gracefully takes its turn, it boldly embraces the realm of Disclosure, embarking on a profound exploration of the intricate interplay between culture and the transgender identities and experiences that dwell within it.

The narrative deftly navigates these uncharted waters, inviting contemplation and fostering a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by the transgender community in their quest for acceptance and recognition.

Stream it or skip it?

The Hulu documentary Queenmaker: The Making of an It Girl offers an overview of the heiress-celebrity scene that thrived during the turn of the 21st century.

The film explores well-known figures such as Paris and Nicky Hilton, Nicole Richie, and Tinsley Mortimer, as well as the bloggers who became intertwined with their lives. Notable names like Perez Hilton and Gawker’s Emily Gould rose to prominence by covering these young socialites, who epitomized an era where fame was often gained solely for being famous.

The documentary presents a narrative that highlights the socialites’ party-going lifestyle, camera-friendly poses, and their status as symbols of a celebrity culture obsessed with hollow notoriety.


Also Read

‘Blindspotting’ Season 2: A Blend Of Entertainment, Authenticity, And Impact

The James Kurisunkal Story

However, a captivating twist unfolds as a new character emerges, bringing forth a truly intriguing narrative. Caution is advised for those who plan on watching the documentary and wish to avoid spoilers.

Meet James Kurisunkal, an overweight and isolated teenager from the Midwest, who faced social exclusion due to his brown skin and his homosexuality, while his parents, Indian immigrants, added to his sense of otherness. For James, the vibrant New York party scene and its illustrious icons became a distant lifeline and an all-consuming obsession.

Among these figures, he found himself particularly captivated by Mortimer, the charismatic and privileged Virginian, who later gained recognition as a reality TV personality in the ill-fated series “High Society”.

In a bold move mirroring the trends of the time, he followed suit with the prevailing teenage wave and embarked on an unconventional journey. With the birth of his blog, “Park Avenue Peerage,” he aimed to carve out a distinct niche—one that diverged from the cutthroat nature of his counterparts, although surpassing the level of kindness and gentleness set by Perez Hilton hardly posed a challenge. Nevertheless, his blog gained popularity, and the revelation of the true identity behind its creation sparked a wave of ironic fascination.

Battling Shadows and Shattered Dreams

His remarkable ascent didn’t stop there. New York Magazine recognized his talent and brought him on board as a paid intern, granting him an intimate vantage point within the world he had long admired from afar. Yet, this world, notorious for its resistance to outsiders, proved to be a relentless adversary.

It chewed him up and mercilessly spat him out, leaving him battered and bruised, as he was compelled to retreat back to the University of Illinois. Within the confines of academia, he descended into the dark abyss of drug addiction and profound depression, his spirit shattered.


In a poignant final blog post, he expressed a profound transformation of his perspective: “I’m no longer fascinated by this world,” he wrote in a final blog post. “I’m not impressed. In fact, I’m depressed.”

The story does not come to an end; in fact, it is only the beginning of an extraordinary revelation. Queenmaker delicately and artfully unveils a transformation: James Kurisunkal has emerged as Morgan Olivia Rose, a resilient woman based in Chicago, who has been navigating life primarily as a sex worker.

Director Zackary Drucker, also a trans woman, gracefully steps into the narrative, providing unwavering support to Rose as she molds her own unique story. In a remarkable turn of events, Drucker facilitates a reunion between Rose and Mortimer, two individuals whose paths had diverged dramatically since their last encounter when Rose existed as a vastly different person.

Also Read

Horrors, Thrills, And Chills: Mia Goth’s Versatility In The Horror Genre


Through this captivating journey, Hulu’s documentary transcends its role as a mere account of a particular time and scene, morphing into something alive—a living entity that exudes a certain messiness and disjointedness, yet possesses an inherent spontaneity and unpredictability.


It becomes a vessel for authenticity, inviting us to contemplate the intricate complexities of Rose’s narrative and its intertwined connection to the world of celebrity, status, and image. In this fusion of storytelling, profound ideas surrounding identity unfurl, exploring its symbolism, its fluidity, and the very essence of its meaning.

sawera dedar

Sawera Dedar has been, time and time again, accused of being a self-professed nerd. At one point in life, she stopped taking it as a jab, and that’s when she realized the remarkable potential of her ‘quirks’. Having embraced who she is, she now employs her nerdiness to analyze her favorite films and TV shows. At streamingdigitally, she writes about the newest releases in the entertainment world.

Leave a Reply